The science regarding Chromosome 2 and the possible fusion event are discussed at length in the book Science and Human Origins, ... Darrel at 5:27 claims that we must choose between intelligent design by an engineer or “master puppet-builder,” or evolution by a “loving parent.” This is a strange way of framing things. It was my understanding that this trial was about whether or not Dover … That's just bad design, which certainly wouldn't happen with an intelligent designer. As part of natural genetic changes over time, chromosomes … In this post, I review what we know about the origins of human chromosome 2, and then discuss the new Denisovan findings and their implications. Ed Park, MD 01/20/2016 dr ed park , evolution , research Leave a Comment The smoking gun is that the great ape have two chromosomes which fused to become our single human Chromosome #2. EXPAND ME Irrefutable proof of evolution, along with their 'rebuttals'. Will the next Monkey Trial be in Ohio?" Tomkins, J. and Bergman, J., Telomeres: implications for aging and evidence for intelligent design, J. But this again is consistent with mutations in the several million years since the fusion event, and certainly not with meticulous molecular-level design. Chromosome 2- the “smoking gun” of evolution (or intelligent design?) Ed Park, MD 01/20/2016 dr ed park , evolution , research Leave a Comment The smoking gun is that the great ape have two chromosomes which fused to become our single human Chromosome #2. Calilasseia wrote:And of course, one inconvenient fact that creationists won't touch with a barge pole, is the fact that Linnaeus, sixty two years before Darwin was born, alighted upon the idea that humans and chimpanzees were related, on the basis of comparative anatomy alone, and even wanted to place humans and chimpanzees in the same taxonomic Genus. One of the many interesting findings was that the Denisovans share the same chromosome 2 fusion that modern humans have. This difference in chromosome count is yet another fundamental problem for evolution. Judgment Day: Intelligent Design on Trial || student handout The following idiograms—graphic representations of chromosomes— show only one half of the matched chromosome pair. Creation 25(1):86–97, 2011. Miller and a host of evolutionists have jumped on this alleged chromosomal fusion as evidence that humans, the chimpanzee, and other hominids all descended from one common ancestor. And the Miller Told His Tale: Ken Miller’s Cold (Chromosomal) Fusion Dr. Kenneth Miller was the leadoff hitter for Plaintiffs in the trial over ID in Dover. chromosome-fusion. The evidence from chromosomal fusion, for one, is strikingly ambiguous. Yes, Im using the term proof. The origins of human chromosome 2: a brief review Leave a Reply Cancel reply. Creationists' response to the fusion of human chromosome # 2 Incl. According to evolution, humans have 23 rather than 24 pairs of chromosomes because of a chromosome fusion event in our past history. intelligent design, belief in divine creation Moderators: Calilasseia , DarthHelmet86 , Onyx8 chromosome-fusion. Learn how your comment data is processed. The design hypothesis is essentially debunked, because it can't explain the presence of the two extra telomeres and one extra centromere. The Fusion of chromosome 2 ! Fan, Y. et al., Genomic structure and evolution of the ancestral chromosome fusion site in 2q13-2q14.1 and paralogous regions on other human chromosomes, Genome Research 12:1651–1662, 2002. Chromosomes contain all of our genetic code. The chromosome 2 fusion model of human evolution—part 2: re-analysis of the genomic data by Jeffrey Tomkins and Jerry Bergman A major argument for human evolution from a shared common ancestor with the great apes, particularly chimpanzees, is the ‘chromosome 2 fusion model’. You must be logged in to post a comment. Search for: Recent Posts. But, why such chromosome fusions didn't occur in other primates like Bonobos, Chimpanzees, … Humans have 23 pairs of chromosomes that exist in nearly every cell in the body. Early in our evolutionary history we had 24 pairs of chromosomes, but the fusion event reduced this number to 23. All other things being equal, according to Bayes theorem the chromosomal fusion resulting in chromosome 2 in humans is indeed positive evidence for common descent between humans and the other great apes simply because common descent requires the fusion while creationism does not, even though it might be compatible with the fusion. Humans have 23 pairs including a single chromosome 2 (46 total), while the great apes have 24 pairs including the distinct chromosomes 2A and 2B (48 total). Dr. Alex Malpass and Dr. William Lane Craig’s argument over countable infinities and modal scope fallacy. As I wrote in the previous essay in this series, Intelligent Design advocate Casey Luskin doesn’t think the fusion which produced human chromosome 2 could have become fixed in the human population: Miller may have found good empirical evidence for a chromosomal fusion event. Chromosome 2- the “smoking gun” of evolution (or intelligent design?) Evolution would have been wrong, if the fusion of two primate chromosomes that resulted in Chromosome 2 in humans never happened... Kenneth Miller, a Biologist who gave a lecture “The Collapse of Intelligent Design. Why would an intelligent designer make human chromosome 2 with unnecessary extra telomeres and centromeres?