That's a real shame, because the calculated, vicious babysitter was one of the most underrated One Tree Hill villains of all time. I personally, HATE Nanny Carrie!! If you're a huge One Tree Hill fan, then you definitely remember Nanny Carrie, played by Torrey DeVitto. I mean from trying to get with Nathan, breaking up Haley and Nathan, to stealing little Jamie. While trying to start his agency business, Clayton leaves Tree Hill to try and recruit Katie at a tennis competition. Is it bad that the only reason I want to see Melissa as AD just to see Torrey turn back into her crazy character from One Tree Hill aka Nanny Carrie? Wiki User March 19, 2010 6:53AM. He was born on their graduation day at about the same time as his aunt, being the half-sister of his uncle — Lucas Scott, Lily Roe Scott. She was eventually conquered by Quinn in a harrowing showdown during a storm. If you're a huge One Tree Hill fan, then you definitely remember Nanny Carrie, played by Torrey DeVitto. How does nanny Carrie die in One Tree Hill? I mean from trying to get with Nathan, breaking up Haley and Nathan, to stealing little Jamie. Asked in Drama TV Shows, One Tree Hill Does anyone die in series 6 of One Tree Hill? [Spoiler Alert, if you haven’t seen the complete show] Nannie Carrie was a psychotic person in the show One tree Hill played by Torrey DeVitto who seemed perfectly normal initially. Dan kills her. She came onto the series during Season 5 as Jamie Scott's babysitter… Katie Ryan was a prospective client of Clayton Evans who bore a striking resemblance to his late wife Sara. Ok so this is for all the OTH (One Tree Hill) fans out there. Maybe the One Tree Hill writers received complaints that they hadn't yet exhausted the "crazy stalker" storyline or maybe this one seemed so unique they just couldn't shoot it down. I personally, HATE Nanny Carrie!! She came onto the series during Season 5 as Jamie Scott's babysitter. Katie began to stalk Clay and later shot both him and his girlfriend Quinn James. Related Questions. Ok so this is for all the OTH (One Tree Hill) fans out there. Jamie Scott is the son of Nathan and Haley Scott and older brother of Lydia. Two words: Nanny Carrie.